In 15 years as a retirement advisor, I’ve seen people retire and never look back.
I’ve also seen people retire with plenty of money and spend the first couple of years second-guessing the decision.
So before I tell a client they’re ready, I ask five questions.
If you can honestly answer yes to all five, you may be in a position to retire. Not in a year. Not in five. Now.
Let’s get into it.
Why “Hit Your Number” Isn’t Enough
You’ve probably heard the advice: Wait until you hit your number, and then you’re good to go.
That can be true for some people.
But your number is only one piece of the puzzle.
And if you’re more worried about outliving your money than enjoying it, a number on a spreadsheet won’t change that.
There’s a difference between being able to retire and being ready to retire.
These five questions get at the difference.
1. Does Your Plan Fund the Life You Want?
This is where I see the biggest disconnect.
People lock onto a number. One million. Two million. Five million.
But what does that number represent?
Usually, it’s a number they saw on TV or heard from a friend. It’s not tied to anything about their actual life.
Start somewhere else.
Do you want to play pickleball? Golf? Travel? Spend time with family, read, and enjoy some peace and quiet?
Your answer drives how much income you need. Then you work backwards to the portfolio.
Here’s a simple way to think about it.
Start with what actually hits your bank account each month. Not your salary. Your take-home, after taxes, insurance, and 401(k) contributions.
Now ask which of those expenses will continue into retirement.
Hypothetical example, for illustration only:
You’re spending $10,000 a month today. $2,000 of that is a mortgage that will be paid off by the time you retire. Another $1,000 goes into a brokerage account, which stops once you’re no longer saving.
That leaves $7,000 of existing expenses.
Now add what’s new. Maybe more travel. Maybe more golf. Say that adds $3,000.
You’re back to $10,000 a month.
Next, subtract income that doesn’t come from your portfolio, like Social Security or a pension. Say that’s $4,000 a month.
That leaves a $6,000 monthly gap, or $72,000 a year.
That’s the number your portfolio needs to support.
You didn’t start with a portfolio number. You started with your life, priced it out, and worked backwards.
(These figures are illustrative only. Yours will differ, but the framework holds.)
2. Can Your Portfolio Generate Income Through Any Type of Market?
Having enough saved is only half the equation.
Two people can have the same portfolio and the same expenses, and get very different results.
Why?
How the money is invested.
Here’s an extreme example I’ve actually seen. Someone has “enough.” We ask what it’s invested in. The answer is one single stock.
That’s not a retirement plan. That’s a bet.
A more common version is a portfolio concentrated in one asset class. Maybe all large tech growth. Maybe all S&P 500.
Those are strong asset classes. Most people should consider them as part of a portfolio.
But every asset class goes through long stretches of weak performance.
Here’s why it matters in retirement.
When you’re working and adding to your portfolio, a downturn is uncomfortable. You’re buying at lower prices and waiting for a recovery.
When you’re retired and withdrawing from your portfolio, a downturn early on can do lasting damage. That’s called sequence of returns risk.
Think about the early 2000s. Several rough years for the S&P 500, a recovery, and then 2007 through 2009. Someone retiring into that and withdrawing from an all-S&P portfolio had a very different experience than someone who didn’t.
Retirement investing is a different game.
You’re no longer chasing the best long-term average return. You need assets that don’t all move together, with a mix of conservative and growth investments.
So ask yourself: if the market has a rough stretch, does your income hold up?
If everything is in one place, the answer is probably no.
3. Is Your Healthcare Covered Until Medicare?
This is the biggest misconception I see.
People think they can’t retire before 65 because their insurance comes from their employer.
I understand the thinking. Employer coverage is a nice benefit.
But it’s not the only option.
Stop thinking of health insurance as something your employer must provide. Start thinking of it as a line item in your budget.
COBRA, the marketplace, and a spouse’s plan are all options to explore. The cost and coverage may look different, so price them out.
What bothers me is seeing people who are financially prepared, and ready to stop working, stay in a job for years. Not because they want to. Because they believe leaving before Medicare is irresponsible.
That’s some of the best years of life, traded for a benefit that can be replaced.
Treat it as a planning question, not a roadblock.
4. Do You Have Something to Retire To?
You don’t need every day of retirement mapped out. That’s unrealistic.
But you do need to know who you’re going to be when work stops taking up most of your calendar.
When was the last time you didn’t have a full-time job filling your life?
For many people, that’s 40 years ago.
You’ve changed since then. What you enjoyed at 22 may not be what you enjoy now.
And here’s the hard part.
It’s not hard to do what you want. It’s hard to know what you want.
So start with the big areas of life:
- Health
- Relationships
- Hobbies
- Faith
- Travel
Do you have a general idea of what you’ll do in each?
If relationships matter most, what will you commit to? Even a weekly walk with a neighbor counts.
If your health has taken a back seat, what will you start now, before you retire?
Without something to retire to, too many retirees end up feeling aimless.
5. If You’re Married: Would Your Spouse Be Okay If You Passed Away First?
This one matters more than people give it credit for.
In most couples, one person is the “money person.” They enjoy the spreadsheets, the tracking, the investments.
Nothing wrong with that.
But if you were gone tomorrow, would your spouse know where to log in?
Would they know the high-level plan? Where income comes from? What that Roth conversion strategy you’re so excited about is actually doing?
Too often, the answer is no. I’ve worked with the spouses. They were never brought in.
Your spouse doesn’t need to love the details. They do need to know where to start.
And knowing where to log in isn’t enough.
Have you modeled what happens when one of you passes first?
What happens to Social Security, when one benefit goes away? What happens to your tax bracket, when the thresholds shrink for a single filer?
If one of you outlives the other by a decade or two, those effects add up.
So ask yourself: is the surviving spouse going to be okay?
What If You Answered No to Any of Them?
Don’t panic.
A “no” isn’t a stop sign. It’s a signal on where to dig deeper.
If you answered yes to all five, you may be in a very strong position to retire.
If you didn’t, you now know exactly where to focus.
Want Help Running These Against Your Actual Plan?
That’s exactly what we do at Root Financial.
We’ll walk through these five questions with you, using your real numbers, your real goals, and your real situation.