Thus far this year, our Vista team has grappled with 20+ client situations involving large, appreciated stock positions. Here are a collection of takeaways based on our experience:
Planning should ground the conversation
As much as we can discuss price targets, scenario planning, and unknown variables, most clients don’t want to delay enjoying the fruits of their labor. They typically have delayed long enough. While this almost never results in an all-or-nothing sale, the progression typically starts with 1) selling enough to meet immediate goals 2) setting the table for intermediate goals and regret minimization 3) tax-efficiently handling the glidepath to a portfolio built for intermediate and long-term goals and 4) building in enough slack so the planning and portfolio isn’t a house of cards.
Another way to think about #4 is: count on the original plan not going exactly according to plan. Build in a margin of safety such that adjustments can be made as life events happen.
Regret minimization weighs on all parties.
We typically make sure an uncapped portion of single stock exposure is retained (not collared) to be held for the long-term. Most clients want some to minimize regret in case the stock goes to the moon. Behavioral factors are real for all of us.
Tax-efficient liquidity is often desired.
Many have heard the phrase buy, borrow, die. We don’t want to take it to the extreme, so if we are borrowing against a single stock, we will always collar the position first, get the lowest interest rate possible (typically via box spread loan), and do not go too high on the loan-to-value ratio (LTV). By borrowing without selling, we open all kinds of flexibility for planning and investments.
We’re middling, so either way you can blame your advisor 🙂
If we recommend selling some of the stock, we hope we’re wrong in hindsight. We hope the stock soars and you wish you didn’t sell anything. We also know the opposite is possible–if the stock falls, you’ll wish we’d sold more. Either way, we’re the bad guys: the stock goes up and you wish you never sold, or the stock goes down and you wish you sold much more. The answer that puts your advisor in this position is probably the right one! In case it’s not obvious, there is no perfect solution precisely because we cannot know what the future holds.
The Definition of Learning
Munger once quipped, “Learning is not memorizing information, learning is changing behavior.” Many advisors are vaguely aware of the tools to help with large, appreciated stock positions. They may gather some information but rarely are they changing the way they plan or design portfolios. It’s too bad because the amount of valuable solutions available to independent advisors today is staggering.
This presents a challenge for clients seeking great advice, but a massive opportunity for advisors who are eager to learn and hone their craft to the benefit of clients. There is truly no one-size-fits-all in this realm. Our Vista team is not perfect, but our desire to learn, expand our toolkit, and apply a very modern approach to navigating concentration risk in a robust manner has been incredibly rewarding since we officially launched the team almost a year ago.
We look forward to many more opportunities to leverage these insights to the benefit of our clients in the months and years to come.
–
CONSIDER
David Senra hosts two of my favorite podcasts. He is an overnight success ten years in the making. Him and James have that in common. I’ve found inspiration in the simple idea that we should fight to not lose our inner child and the hopes, dreams, and endless possibilities that come with that mindset.
“I think Muse can give everyone the adulthood they dreamed of in childhood. By the time they have been in a job for a while…all that hope and ambition and ability to dream has been sucked out of them. One of the promises of AI broadly speaking is to keep it [ambition] going…you’re a kid, you have big dreams, use AI, help make those things happen, then dream bigger and bigger.”
– Alexandr Wang, Cheif AI Officer at Meta and CEO of Scale AI
“The summer after 8th grade, I attended the Governor’s School of Rhode Island. I wasn’t sure what to expect. On the first night, I was captivated by a speech given by one of the leaders. I remember goosebumps rising on my arms as he spoke: “This program is a special opportunity. It’s up to you to take advantage of it. You have a choice: you can waste the next couple months and not accomplish that much, or you can go all in. This is an opportunity to go deep on a project and do the best work you’ve ever done, but you have to decide if you want it. I learned what it meant to go all in. The magical connection between intensity of focus and the end result. If I put my whole heart and soul into a project, I had it in me to create really cool stuff.”
– Brad Jacobs, CEO of QXO and builder of 8 billion-dollar companies
Each of us is immensely capable.
–
Let’s get after it this week!
Brooks
The examples provided are hypothetical and for illustrative purposes only. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The information presented should not be construed as investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or implement a particular strategy.
Advisory services are offered through Root Financial Partners, LLC, an SEC registered investment adviser.